I know how to get loads of smilies for this forum!!!
Just look at my forum - it uses same functions as yours... :) Post whatever and take a look - must be 100+ smilies, easily accessable on this phpBB forum... :) http://kota.freeforumsite.com/

We already tried. Forumer doesn't allow us to add any more smilies. I use forumup and I'm allowed to add more smilies but for some reason this community won't allow us to put more smilies.

that's superiourly lame if you ask me. but if you go to other forums you can copy the image location and if you know how to post images then you're all set.